The use of video arbitration, also known as VAR (Video Assistant Referee), sparks intense debates in the world of football, particularly after controversial decisions on the field. The incident that occurred during the match between Wolfsburg and Stuttgart highlights the shortcomings of the current system, emphasizing the need for urgent reform.
A Disconcerting Incident in the Bundesliga
During the match between Wolfsburg and Stuttgart, referee Jablonski made a regrettable decision by sanctioning player Karazor with a red card after an alleged foul on Arnold. Subsequently, he was forced to admit that the roles were reversed and that the referee had penalized the wrong player. This situation illustrates a striking example of the ineffectiveness of VAR, which failed to correct a clear error.
Indeed, VAR is only activated for definitive expulsions (red cards), meaning it is ineffective in the case of yellow cards, even when a second yellow card leads to a player’s expulsion. This situation raises questions about the true role of the video referee when it comes to one of the most obvious errors of the season.
Call for VAR Reform
The VAR system, introduced in the Bundesliga in 2017, requires re-evaluation and a return to clear foundations. Karl Jablonski himself has expressed the wish that any expulsion, whether due to a red card or a second yellow card, could be subject to VAR review. Thus, a team should not benefit from an undue advantage when key decisions are mismade.
The controversy surrounding this decision has sparked debates among VAR critics, who instead argue for a reduction in its use, while it becomes increasingly clear that measures must be taken to improve its effectiveness. For example, phases leading to a goal should also be examined, considering that errors in these crucial moments could influence the course of the match.
The Possibility of a Challenge
A suggestion to improve the system includes the introduction of a challenge rule, similar to that existing in other sports, allowing coaches to request a video review of a decision during the match. This possibility would give teams some control and ensure that fundamental decisions are adequately examined.
Influential figures in the football world, such as Rainer Bonhof, president of Gladbach and former world champion, also support this proposal. In the event of a conflict like the one observed in Wolfsburg, Stuttgart could have benefited from this measure, allowing Karazor to remain on the field and potentially avoiding an unjust decision against Arnold.
In the interest of fair play and the integrity of the game, it is imperative that VAR undergoes a rigorous evaluation and a complete overhaul to better serve football. These changes could contribute to a fairer game and a better experience for fans.
Source : www.bild.de